Must and can't

   
 A. Study this example:
  We use must to say that we feel sure something is true:
  * You've been travelling all day. You must be tired. (Travelling is tiring and you've been travelling all day, so you must be tired.)
  * 'Jim is a hard worker.' 'Jim? A hard worker? You must be joking. He's very lazy.'
  * Carol must get very bored in her job. She does the same thing every day.
  We use can't to say that we feel sure something is not possible:
  * You've just had lunch. You can't be hungry already. (People are not normally hungry just after eating a meal. You've just eaten, so you can't be hungry.)
  * Brian said he would definitely be here before 9.30. It's 10 o'clock now and he's never late. He can't be coming.
  * They haven't lived here for very long. They can't know many people.
  Study the structure:
  I/you/he (etc.) must/can't be (tired/hungry/at work etc.)
  I/you/he (etc.) must/can't be (doing/coming/joking etc.) do/go/know/have etc.
  I/you/he (etc.) must/can't do/go/know/have etc.
    B. For the past we use must have (done) and can't have (done). Study this example:
  George is outside his friends' house.
  He has rung the doorbell three times but nobody has answered.
  They must have gone out. (otherwise they would have answered)
  * The phone rang but I didn't hear it. I must have been asleep.
  * I've lost one of my gloves. I must have dropped it somewhere.
  * Jane walked past me without speaking. She can't have seen me.
  * Tom walked straight into a wall. He can't have been looking where he was going.
  Study the structure:
  I/you/he (etc.) must/can't have been (asleep/at work etc.)
  I/you/he (etc.) must/can't have been (doing/working etc.)
  I/you/he (etc.) must/can't have done /gone/known/had etc.
  Couldn't have ... is possible instead of can't have...:
  * She couldn't have seen me.
  * Tom couldn't have been looking where he was going.

    EXERCISES

  28.1 Put in must or can't.
  1. You've been travelling all day. You must be very tired.
  2. That restaurant --- be very good. It's always full of people.
  3. That restaurant --- be very good. It's always empty.
  4. You're going on holiday next week. You --- be looking forward to it.
  5. It rained every day during their holiday, so they --- have had a very nice time.
  6. Congratulations on passing your exam. You --- be very pleased.
  7. You got here very quickly. You --- have walked very fast.
  8. Bill and Sue go away on holiday very often, so they --- be short of money.
  28.2 Complete the sentences with a verb in the correct form.
  1. I've lost one of my gloves. I must have dropped it somewhere.
  2. They haven't lived here for long. They can't know many people.
  3. Ted isn't at work today. He must --- ill.
  4. Ted wasn't at work last week. He must --- ill.
  5. (The doorbell rings) I wonder who that is. It can't --- Mary. She's still at work at this time.
  6. Carol knows a lot about films. She must --- to the cinema a lot.
  7. Look. Jack is putting on his hat and coat. He must --- out.
  8. I left my bike outside the house last night and this morning it isn't there any more. Somebody must --- it.
  9. Ann was in a very difficult situation. It can't --- easy for her.
  10. There is a man walking behind us. He has been walking behind us for the last 20 minutes. He must --- us.
  28.3 Read the situations and use the words in brackets to write sentences with must have and can't have.
  1. The phone rang but I didn't hear it. (I/asleep)
  _I must have been asleep._
  2. Jane walked past me without speaking. (she/see/me)
  _She can't have seen me._
  3. The jacket you bought is very good quality. (it/very expensive)
  4. I haven't seen the people next door for ages. (they/go away)
  5. I can't find my umbrella. (I/leave/it in the restaurant last night)
  6. Don passed the exam without studying for it. (the exam/very difficult)
  7. She knew everything about our plans. (she/listen/to our conversation)
  8. Fiona did the opposite of what I asked her to do. (she/understand/what I said)
  9. When I woke up this morning, the light was on. (I/forget/to turn it off)
  10. The lights were red but the car didn't stop. (the driver I see/the red light)
  11. I was woken up in the middle of the night by the noise next door. (the neighbours/have/a party)

the answer

  28.1
  2 must  3 can't
  4 must  5 can't
  6 must  7 must  8 can't
  28.2
  3 be
  4 have been
  5 be
  6 go or have been
  7 be going
  8 have taken/have stolen
  9 have been
  10 be following
  28.3
  3 It must have been very expensive.
  4 They must have gone away.
  5 I must have left it in the restaurant last night.
  6 The exam can't have been very difficult.
  7 She must have been listening to our conversation./She must have listened to.
  8 She can't have understood what I said.
  9 I must have forgotten to turn it off.
  10 The driver can't have seen the red light.
  11 The neighbours must have been having a party.